A SALUTARY INFLUENCE As was to be expected, the board action in December 1923 did not end the discussion. On March 12,1924 the Gettysburgian speculated that "sufficient pressure from outside sources" may "force the Board to reconsider their action." On April 30 the paper printed a letter from Joseph B. Baker, then a Lutheran pastor in Indiana, Pennsylvania, and one of the seven board members who had been the minority several months earlier. Disappointment and sorrow were words he used to describe his own feelings. "When we select athletes we judge muscle, when we select singers we judge voices, when we select students we ought to judge brains," he wrote. "To use any other basis of selection is to display a pathetic misunderstanding of the v...