A SALUTARY INFLUENCE judgment, the most important single criterion to be used was character.109 He was fond of telling students that it was not the prize which they obtained in life which counts, but rather the race which they run. Time and again he argued that the main objective of Gettysburg College was to help produce Christian gentlemen. "When you scratch the skin of a Gettysburg man" he said, "you find underneath a gentleman."110 His method of accomplishing his end, he often said, was to lead students rather than to drive them. He much preferred to give those of his "boys" who needed it a good "talking to" rather than resort to established disciplinary procedures. "It has always been my contention that a good talking," he told a Gettys...