Chinese Theories of Anti-Modern or Alternative Modernity: Arif Dirlik, Liu Kang, and Wang Hui

In Yuyu Wu’s article, There and Back Again: A Critical Study on \u27Anti-modern Modernity,\u27 the author discusses the arguments about anti-modern modernity, raised by Arif Dirlik, Kang Liu and Hui Wang, and compares different contexts in which China’s modernity has been understood and interpreted. Both Dirlik and Liu reflect upon western Critical Theory through analysis of the Chinese experience, while Wang brings this theory back to China. However, in this two-way journey, a structural change occurs. By justifying China’s historical experience through abstract western theories, western Critical Theory has not only lost its sharp critical edge, but also transmogrified into an excuse for the Chinese experience. As a result, the insights of western Critical Theory become blind spots for interpreting the Chinese experience