Species boundaries in bats: a philosophical, morphometric, environmental, and phylogenetic analysis of the genera Anoura, Carollia and Sturnira

Thesis (Ph.D.)--Boston UniversitySpecies are central to evolutionary biology, systematics and taxonomy. However, their precise definition and diagnosis is not straightforward. Species may be purely nominal constructs of the human mind or they may be real entities. Part of the difficulty of defining and diagnosing species lies in the continuous nature of variation from the level of the individual to the population, subspecies and species. It is here where systematics and taxonomy become challenging and exciting tools for understanding life on the planet. For bats, most of the efforts to describe and differentiate species have been qualitative. This may have worked in earlier times, during the first efforts to describe and name species. But, more recently, our perspectives have become sharper and the shortcomings of the qualitative approach have become obvious. This thesis is a collection of published essays, submitted studies, and ongoing research into the boundaries of bat species. In each chapter, I stress that species are not ideas or categories in the mind, but are real entities, based on testable hypotheses about the distribution of character states within multiorganismal entities. Therefore, these hypotheses and distributions of character states should optimally be analyzed through the prism of statistical inference. The dynamics of size and shape in the genus Anoura are discussed in the context of the space occupied by the different species within the genus, with novel insights into the interpretation of the distribution of these species in morphospace. For boundaries in the genus Carollia, I reassess current taxonomical knowledge, analyze morphological variation in relation to the environment, and the statistical uncertainty of species discrimination. In the species-rich genus Sturnira, I analyze a large morphological dataset for several species from Ecuador, describe a new species (S. peria) synonymize an old one (S. luisi), and provide a new perspective on phylogenetic relationships and species boundaries