Financial conditions indexes

This paper provides an exposition of the nature, means of estimation and uses of Financial Conditions Indexes (FCIs) and their relationship to the more common Monetary Conditions Indexes (MCIs) that are used by market analysts, international organisations and central banks. Using panel datasets for Western Europe we explore how asset prices, particularly house and stock prices, can provide useful additional indicators of future changes in output and inflation. We find a clear role for house prices but a poorly determined relationship for stock prices. Unfortunately the most useful role for FCIs comes from their incorporation of high frequency data and the opportunity this gives for extracting information about changes in market expectations for inflation and output. This helps market participants make judgements about likely central bank reactions and helps central banks assess the stance of policy between forecasts. While stock prices are high frequency, house prices are not. At quarterly frequency central banks in particular will want to use traditional economic forecasting methods and summary indicators like FCIs will have only a limited role. We illustrate how such an FCI can be used, drawing on monthly data for Finland.UnpublishedNon Peer ReviewedBaxter, M (1994) `Real Exchange Rates and Real Interest Differentials : Have we Missed the Business Cycle Relationship?', Journal of Monetary Economics, vol.33, pp.5-37. Bernrnanke, B and Gertler, M (1995) `Inside the Black Box : the Credit Channel of Monetary Transmission', Journal of Economic Perspectives, vol.9 (4), pp.27-48. Bernrnanke, B and Gertler, M (1999) `Monetary Policy and Asset Price Volatility', in New Challenges for Monetary Policy, Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, pp .77-128. Black, R Cassino, V, Drew, A, Hansen, E, Hunt, B, Rose D and Scott, A (1997) `The Forecasting and Policy System : the Core Model', Reserve Bank of New Zealand Research Paper 43 . Bryan, M F, Cechetti, S G and O'Sullivan, R (2001) `Asset Prices in the Measurement of Inflation', De Nederlandsche Bank Staff Report no .62. Byangos, V. (2000) `A Real Monetary Conditions Index for the Philippines : Is It Useful?', Institute of Social Studies, The Hague Working Paper no.309. Case, K E, Quigley, J M and Shiller, R J (2001) `Comparing Wealth Effects : The Stock Market ver sus the Housing Market' Cowles Foundation Discussion Paper no 1335 . Cechetti, S G, Genburg, H, Lipsky, J and Wadhwani, S (2000) Asset Prices and Central Bank Policy, Geneva Report on the World Economy no .2, International Center for Monetary and Banking Studies and CEPR . Chiuri, M C and Jappellili, T (2000) `Financial Market Imperfections and Home Ownership : a Comparative Study', Working Paper 44, Centre for Studies in Economics and Finance, University of Salernrno . Eika, K H, Ericsson, N R and Nymoen, R (1997) `Hazards in Implementing a Monetary Conditions Index', Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, vol 58 (4), pp. 765-90. Genburg, H (2001) `Asset Prices, Monetary Policy and Macroeconomic Stability', De Nederlandsche Bank Staff Report no 64 . Gerlach, S and Smets, F (1996) 'MCIs and Monetary Policy in Small Open Economies under Floating Rates', BIS, mimeo . Goldman Sachs (2001) `South Africa : Easier Monetary Conditions Limit Room for Rate Cuts in 2001', EMEA Economics Analyst, issue 01/05, pp .6-8. Goodhart, C A E (2001) `What Weight Should Be Given to Asset Prices in the Measurement of Inflation?', Economic Journal, vol . I l l (June), pp.F336-57 . Goodhart, C A E and Hofmann, B (2000) `Asset Prices and the Conduct of Monetary Policy', Sveriges Riksbank and Stockholm School of Economics conference on Asset Markets and Monetary Policy, Stockholm, June . Grande, G (1997) `Properties of the Monetary Conditions Index', Banca d'Italia Temi di Discussionn no 324 . lacoviello, M (2000) `House Prices and the Macroeconomy in Europe : Results from a Structural VAR Analysis', European Central Bank Working Paper no . 18, April . Jacobsen, T, Jansson, P, Vredin, A and Warne, A (1998) `A VAR Model for Monetary Policy Analysis in a Small Open Economy', Sveriges Riksbank . King, M (1994) `Debt Deflation : Theory and Evidence', European Economic Review, vol.38, pp.419-35 . Mayes, D G (1979) The Property Boom, Oxford: Martin Robertson . Mayes,D G (1999) `The Evolution of Voluntary Rules for the European Central Bank', Contemporary Politics and Economics of Europe, vol.8 (4), pp.357-86. Mayes, D G and Viren, M (1998) `The Exchange Rate and Monetary Conditions in the Euro Area', Bank of Finland Discussion Paper 27/98 Mayes, D G and Viren, M (2000a) `Asymmetry and the Problem of Integration in the Euro Area', Bank of Finland Discussion Paper 11/2000 Mayes, D G and Viren, M (2000b) `The Exchange Rate and Monetary Conditions in the Euro Area', Weltwirtschafftliches Archiv, vol . 136 (2), pp.199-231 . Meltzer, A H (1995) `Monetary, Credit and (Other) Transmission Processes : a Monetarist Perspective', Journal of Economic Perspectives, vol.9 (4), pp.49-72 . Muellbauer, J (1992) `Anglo-German Differences in Housing Market Dynamics : The Role of Institutions and Macroeconomic Policy', European Economic Review, vol.36, pp.539- 48. Reserve Bank of New Zealand (1997) `Recommendation to the 1997 CPI Revision Advisory Committee' (May) http://www.rbnz.govt.nz/cpi.htm . Roger, S (1993) `Asset Prices and Monetary Policy', mimeo, Reserve Bank of New Zealand . Rudebusch, G and Svensson, L E 0 (1998) `Policy Rules for Inflation Targeting' NBER Working Paper 6512 . Stock, J and Watson, M (2000) `Forecasting Output and Inflation : the role of asset prices', Sveriges Riksbank and Stockholm School of Economics conference on Asset Markets and Monetary Policy, Stockholm, June. Soderlind, P and Svensson, L E 0 (1997) `New Techniques to Extract Market Expectations from Financial Instruments' Journal of Monetary Economics, vol.40 (2), pp.373-429. Svensson, L E 0 (2001) `What is Wrong with Taylor Rules? Using Judgement in Monetary Policy through Targeting Rules', mimeo July Valckx, N (2001) `Factors Affecting Asset Price Expectations : Fundamentals and Policy Variables', Bank of Finland Discussion Paper 13/2001 . Winkler, B (2000) `Which Kind of Transparency? On the Need for Clarity in Monetary Policy Making', European Central Bank Working Paper no.26