GIS, expert systems and interoperability

Part of the GeoComputation '96 Special Issue 96/25; follow the "related link" to download the entire collection as a single document.How should geographic information systems be developed? There is a strong demand from users for enhanced functionality and power. Vendors can and do respond to these demands. But where will this lead? Will the result be one all-embracing and all-conquering program or geographic information system (GIS)? A GIS could grow to incorporate all statistical functions, all visualisation techniques, all data management functions etc. It is possible to perceive a scenario in which GIS is developed to ‘bloatware’ proportions. An alternative scenario is one in which a GIS is interfaced with other software systems. Embedding database bridges and other product-specific links, providing data import and export routines, and system calls are all ways of interfacing GIS with other systems. GIS vendors could opt to produce a ‘linkware’ GIS, interfaced to as many third party systems as possible. Given these two alternatives to GIS development, an interesting set of questions arises. How far do vendors go with enhancing their systems compared with interfacing with third party systems? Is there a balance? Or do GIS users just keep calling for ‘more’, regardless of the solution set? There is a balance. GIS is likely to be developed by being enhanced AND by being interfaced with third party software. In a way, this is a third developmental track leading to an increasingly functional GIS whose ability to interact with other systems is greatly improved. This interoperable GIS allows flexible combinations of systems components while still providing a comprehensive range of spatial operations and analytical functions. Of these three developmental tracks, this paper presents an example of what can be achieved with the interoperable GIS. Expert systems are introduced along with the client/server and object-oriented paradigms. By using these paradigms, a generic, spatial, rule-based toolbox called SES (spatial expert shell) has been created. SES is described using examples and contrasted with other documented expert system-GIS linkages. But first integration is modelled in three dimensions to highlight the need for improvements in how GISs can interact with other systems.UnpublishedOpen GIS Consortium, Inc. 1996. Open GIS. WWW ref: http://www.opengis.org. Bleecker, M., Hutson, J. L., and Waltman, S. W. 1990. Mapping groundwater contamination potential using integrated simulation modeling and GIS. Proceedings of Application of geographic information systems, simulation models, and knowledge-based systems for landuse management, Blacksburg, VA. Booch, G. 1994. Object-oriented analysis and design, The Benjamin/Cummings Publishing Company Inc., Redwood City, California. Burrough, P. A. 1986. Principles of geographical information systems for land resources assessment, Oxford University Press. Burrough, P. A. 1992. Development of intelligent geographical information system. International journal of geographical information systems, 6(1). Crossland, M. D. 1990. HyrdoLOGIC - a prototype GIS expert system for examining an AI application in a GIS environment. Proceedings of GIS/LIS '90. Davis, J. R., Cuddy, S. M., Laut, P., Goodspeed, M. J., and Whigham, P. A. 1991. Testing of soil moisture prediction model for army land managers. Journal of irrigation and drainage engineering, 117(4), p. 476-489. Durkin, J. 1994. Expert systems: design and development, Macmillan Publishing. Fedra, D. K. 1993. GIS and environmental modeling. In Environmental modeling with GIS, M. Goodchild, B. Parks, and L. Steyaert, eds., Oxford University Press. Fedra, K. 1995. Decision support for natural resources management: models, GIS and expert systems. AI Applications, 9(3), p. 3-19. Fischer, M. M. 1994. From conventional to knowledge-based geographic information systems. Computers, environment and urban systems, 18(4), p. 233-42. Fisher, P. F., Mackaness, W. A., Peacegood, G., and Wilkinson, G. G. 1988. Artificial intelligence and expert systems in geodata processing. Progress in physical geography, 12, p. 371-388. Goodchild, M., Haining, R., and Wise, S. 1992. Integrating GIS and spatial data analysis: problems and possibilities. International journal of geographical information systems, 6(5), p. 407-423. Jackson, P. 1990. Introduction to expert systems, Addison-Wesley Publishing Co. Lam, D. C. L., and Swayne, D. A. 1993. An expert system approach of integrating hydrological database, models and GIS: application of the RAISON System. Proceedings of HydroGIS 93: Application of geographical information systems in hydrology and water resources, Vienna, IAHS Publication 211, p. 23. Lein, J. K. 1992. Modeling environmental impact using an expert-geographic information system. Proceedings of GIS/LIS '92, San Jose, CA, USA, p. 436-44. Leung, Y. 1993. Towards the development of an intelligent spatial decision support system. In Geographic information systems, spatial modelling and policy evaluation, M. Fischer and P. Nijkamp, eds., Springer-Verlag. Lilburne, L. 1996. The integration challenge. Proceedings of SIRC '96, Dunedin. Loh, D. K., and Rykiel, E. J. 1992. Integrated resource management systems: coupling expert systems with database management and GIS. Environmental management, 16(2), p. 167-177. Nyerges, T. L. 1992. Coupling GIS and spatial analytical models. Proceedings of 5th international symposium on spatial data handling, Charleston, South Carolina, p. 534-543. Robinson, V. B., Frank, A. U., and Karimi, H. A. 1987. Expert systems for GIS in resource management. AI Applications, 1(1). Sharma, J., Flewelling, D. M., and Egenhofer, M. J. 1994. A qualitative spatial reasoner. Proceedings of 6th international symposium on spatial data handling, p. 665-681. Smith, T. R., and Yiang, J. 1991. Knowledge-based approaches in GIS. In Geographical information systems: principles and applications, D. J. Maguire, M. F. Goodchild, and D. W. Rhind, eds., Longman Group UK Ltd., Marlow, UK. Zhu, X., and Healey, R. 1992. Towards intelligent spatial decision support: integrating geographical information systems and expert systems. Proceedings of GIS/LIS '92