Retinoic Acid Inhibition of Collagenase and Gelatinase Expression in Human Skin Fibroblast Cultures. Evidence for a Dual Mechanism

Human skin fibroblast cultures have been employed to study the effects of a variety of vitamin A analogues (retinoids) on the expression of two enzymes involved in collagen degradation in the skin, collagenase and a gelatinolytic protease. In normal and recessive dystrophic epidermolysis bullosa fibroblast cultures, retinoic acid compounds were effective inhibitors of the accumulation of both enzymes in the culture medium with half-maximal inhibitions occurring at 0.25–1 μM for collagenase and at 3–6 μM for the gelatinolytic protease. Various retinoids exhibited differing degrees of inhibitory actions, so that at a 1 μM concentration, relative inhibitions were: 13-cis-retinoic acid > all-trans-retinoic acid > aromatic retinoid (Ro 10-9359) >> retinol. The retinoic acid-mediated decrease in collagenase activity was accompanied by a parallel decrease in immunoreactive collagenase protein, suggesting that the retinoic acids were acting to inhibit synthesis of the enzyme. However, an additional effect of these agents was encountered. Although the retinoids themselves had no direct collagenase inhibitory action, medium derived from cultures maintained in these retinoids showed direct inhibitory capacity which was dependent both on the concentration of retinoic acid and on the length of time in culture. The results suggest that the retinoic acids modulate collagenase in vitro by two mechanisms: by decreasing the synthesis of enzyme protein and by modulating the expression of an inhibitory molecule