Local and remote matrix responses to chondrocyte-laden collagen scaffold implantation in extensive articular cartilage defects

SummaryChondrocyte-laden collagen scaffolds were evaluated in extensive cartilage defects in an equine model. Arthroscopic techniques were used to implant a chondrocyte-collagen culture product in 15-mm defects in the lateral trochlear ridge of the femoropatellar joint of 12 horses. Ungrafted control defects were formed in the opposite joint. Groups of six horses were terminated at 4 and 8 months after implantation and the repair sites, adjacent cartilage, and remote cartilage within each femoropatellar joint examined biochemically. Eight months following surgery the relative proportions of type II collagen in grafted and ungrafted defects, determined using the ratio of cyanogen bromide cleavage products α1(II)CB10/α2(I)CB3,5, were not significantly different (31.57 ± 2.76% and 26.88 ± 2.76%, respectively). Aggrecan content was significantly improved in grafted defects (85.61 ± 6.51 and 74.91 ± 10.31 μg/mg dry weight). Cartilage surrounding grafted defects also showed improved maintenance of cartilage glycosaminoglycan content. Thus, chondrocyte grafting in collagen scaffold vehicles improved the aggrecan content in extensive cartilage defects and surrounding normal cartilage. However, given the continued disparity between repair tissue and normal cartilage aggrecan content, and the low proportion of type II collagen in grafted defects, the utility of collagen scaffolds for chondrocyte grafting of large cartilage defects seems limited