Valve-Incompetent foramen ovale in premature infants with ductus arteriosus: A Doppler echocardiographic study

In a 1 year period, 56 neonates with a clinical diagnosis of ductus arteriosus had Doppler echocardiographic confirmation of the ductus; 33 (59%) had additional, turbulent left to right flow at the atrial level through a valve-incompetent foramen ovale. Normalized left atrial dimensions in the group with the atrial shunt were significantly larger than when there was a competent foramen ovale; when the ductus closed and left atrial enlargement receded, the atrial shunt disappeared. However, several infants with large left chambers had no interatrial shunting. When the atrial shunt was present, there were up to three flow pulses, corresponding to atrial systole, ventricular systole and ventricular diastole, but these were frequently fused into two pulses or even one pulse per cycle. The atrial septal morphology provided supporting clues: general bowing of the septum or a localized bulge in the region of the foramen ovale indicated relatively high left atrial pressure, and frequently a slitlike dropout could be seen at the superior edge of the foramen.During the study, three additional neonates with a ductus arteriosus were found to have a secundum atrial septal defect with a typical echographic image, “match-head” appearance of the septal rim of the defect, but the Doppler flow patterns were indistinguishable from those of a valve-incompetent foramen ovale. The hemodynamic effects of the interatrial shunt, from either cause, seemed slight during the hospital course, but the presence of a valve-incompetent foramen ovale indicated a relatively large ductal shunt. Quantification of the ductal shunt, however, continues to rely primarily on measurement of the left atrial and ventricular size