Nondeterministic functions and the existence of optimal proof systems

AbstractWe provide new characterizations of two previously studied questions on nondeterministic function classes: Q1: Do nondeterministic functions admit efficient deterministic refinements?Q2: Do nondeterministic function classes contain complete functions? We show that Q1 for the class NPMVt is equivalent to the question whether the standard proof system for SAT is p-optimal, and to the assumption that every optimal proof system is p-optimal. Assuming only the existence of a p-optimal proof system for SAT, we show that every set with an optimal proof system has a p-optimal proof system. Under the latter assumption, we also obtain a positive answer to Q2 for the class NPMVt.An alternative view on nondeterministic functions is provided by disjoint sets and tuples. We pursue this approach for disjoint NP-pairs and its generalizations to tuples of sets from NP and coNP with disjointness conditions of varying strength. In this way, we obtain new characterizations of Q2 for the class NPSV. Question Q1 for NPSV is equivalent to the question of whether every disjoint NP-pair is easy to separate. In addition, we characterize this problem by the question of whether every propositional proof system has the effective interpolation property. Again, these interpolation properties are intimately connected to disjoint NP-pairs, and we show how different interpolation properties can be modeled by NP-pairs associated with the underlying proof system