Tree Mortality After a Hot Drought: Distinguishing Density-Dependent and -Independent Drivers and Why It Matters

Hot drought is a climate phenomenon that has received much attention lately for its potential to disrupt forest function worldwide. A sharp increase in tree mortality associated with this climate pattern is often cast as a disturbance, in which high temperature is responsible for causing exceptional rates of mortality across species. The alternative interpretation is simply that drought kills trees species in a density-dependent manner, related to the water deficit experienced by individual trees. To evaluate the evidence for density-dependent vs. -independent dynamics, we conducted censuses on 30 m × 30 m plots across 30 sites in Ashe juniper (Juniperus ashei) woodlands on the Edwards Plateau of central Texas, USA, 4 years after the hot drought of 2011. We hypothesized that variation in crown mortality of the two most dominant species, Ashe juniper and live oak (Quercus virginiana and Q. fusiformis), could be attributed to tree size, stand density, precipitation amount and/or bedrock depth; factors we considered indicative of density (resource)-dependent dynamics. We further hypothesized that crown mortality in subordinate species and the occurrence of resprouting in trees whose crowns had died would be more strongly controlled by air temperature, vapor pressure deficit, or aspect, acting independently of density. Through model selection analysis, we identified the most parsimonious binomial regression models for crown death in Ashe juniper, live oak and the understory shrub Texas persimmon (Diospyros texana). In Ashe juniper populations, overall crown mortality was 20% and largely followed hypothesized patterns. Live oak had an overall crown mortality rate of 23%, which declined rather than increased with tree density, and no evidence that crown death was linked to atmospheric conditions. Further in support of hypotheses, crown mortality in Texas persimmon and resprouting in Ashe juniper and live oak were significantly affected by exposure to hot and dry conditions and not by density-dependent factors. A surprise finding was the positive effect of bedrock depth on crown mortality. Based on data analysis, we hypothesized that excess precipitation in 2010 was stored in the fractured bedrock below the soil horizon, especially on sites where the soil layer was thin. In the following drought year, this “rock-stored” water rescued larger Ashe juniper trees and live oak trees from crown death, presumably because they had roots in the fractured rock zone