Comprehensive inter-comparison of INSAT multispectral rainfall algorithm estimates and TMPA 3B42-RT V7 estimates across different climate regions of India during southwest monsoon period

The main objective of this study is to validate and inter-compare two Near-Real-Time Satellite Rainfall Estimates (NRT-SREs): INSAT Multispectral Rainfall Algorithm (IMSRA, simple blended product) and TMPA 3B42-RT V7 (3B42-RT, multisatellite product) across India. This study aims to provide some insight into the error characteristics of both the NRT-SREs to the algorithm developers and end users by inter-comparing the daily rainfall estimates during the southwest monsoon period of 2010-2013. This study utilizes various volumetric statistics and categorical statistics to understand and evaluate the performance of NRT-SREs in terms of both spatial and volumetric error characteristics (hit, miss, and false error) at different rainfall thresholds across different Koppen-Geiger climate regions of India using the gridded gauge data provided by Indian Meteorological Department as reference dataset. A detailed statistical evaluation shows that the 3B42-RT performs comparatively better than the IMSRA across India. The results indicate that both IMSRA and 3B42-RT have a general tendency of overestimating the low rainfall rates (0 - 2.5 mm/day) and underestimating the high rainfall rates (> 35.5 mm/day). At lower threshold values (0 and 2.5 mm/day), it is found that the miss error is dominant in IMSRA, whereas the false error is dominant in 3B42RT. As the threshold increases (7.5 and 35.5 mm/day), both the miss and false errors increase in both SREs. Additionally, the spatial analysis of the results clearly indicate that the performance of the tested NRT-SREs is not uniform across different climatic regions, an important aspect to be considered for development/ improvement of the tested NRT-SRE algorithms