Administrative court control in taxation matters

Polazeći od aktualnog uređenja upravnosudske kontrole u poreznim stvarima, u radu se, nakon kratkog prikaza normativnopravnog okvira kontrole u poreznim stvarima, daje prikaz određenih pokazatelja provedbe upravne i upravnosudske kontrole u poreznim stvarima. Iskustva primjene upravne kontrole u poreznim stvarima i analiza dostupnih pokazatelja recentne upravnosudske kontrole u poreznim stvarima povod su traženju novih rješenja učinkovitije zaštite prava poreznih obveznika, ali i ostvarenja zadaća poreznih tijela. Promjene poreznih sustava koje se događaju u okruženju imaju učinke i na hrvatski poreznopravni okvir pa se u radu razmatraju mogući pravci razvoja i ustrojavanja alternativnih oblika rješavanja sporova u području oporezivanja. Za prikaz mogućeg razvoja kontrolnih mehanizama u poreznom pravu odabrana je uspostava arbitražnog pravosudnog sustava u poreznim stvarima. Kontekst pojavljivanja alternativnih oblika rješavanja sporova u poreznim stvarima nameće pitanje jesu li promjene u provedbi kontrole u poreznim stvarima evolucijske naravi.Starting with the current organisation of administrative court control in taxation matters, this paper, after a brief overview of the normative legal framework of control in such matters, provides an analysis of certain indicators of administrative and administrative court control implementation in taxation matters. The experience of the application of administrative control in taxation matters and an analysis of accessible indicators of recent administrative court control in taxation matters has triggered the search for new solutions for more effective protection of taxpayers’ rights and for achieving the tasks of taxation bodies. Occurring changes to taxation systems also affect the Croatian taxation legal framework. Therefore, this paper considers the possible directions of development and the organisation of alternative forms for dispute resolution in the area of taxation. This overview of possible control mechanism directions in taxation law includes an arbitration judicial system for taxation matters. The context for the appearance of alternative forms of dispute resolution in taxation matters poses the question of whether changes to the implementation of control in taxation matters is of an evolutionary nature