Protected area expansion and conservation stewardship in the Olifants Catchment: mechanisms, patterns and benefits

State Conservation Areas (SCAs), as state-owned and -run parks, form the foundation of recognised conservation actions. However, park expansion on the scale required to meet urgent conservation targets is limited by state budgets and parks are increasingly framed in the context of advancing broader societal needs. Motivating for the need to assess the efficacy of alternative conservation strategies, as both contrasting governance and legal mechanisms, this study aimed to rapidly assess the role of private land conservation (PLC) strategies in expanding protection. In particular, this included the role of emerging stewardship approaches, by using semi-structured interviews with park implementers on a national scale. Evaluating the biodiversity and ecosystem service representation and complementarity of contrasting conservation strategies on a catchment scale, using open-source spatial data was employed. Questionnaires tested park managers’ perceptions of benefits across different strategies in a conservation-oriented landscape. Results indicate a strategic shift toward PLC strategies to expand parks in the form of formalised, well-planned and supported contractual and stewardship agreements. SCAs are vital baselines for biodiversity and ecosystem service representation in the catchment with a variety of private mechanisms supplementing protection, especially in highly contested areas. The perceived benefits rated by managers revealed interesting links between benefits and contrasting governance types, legal mechanisms, legal status, size and age of reserves. State parks may be more relevant for generating socio-cultural benefits, while private parks, through the need to remain economically viable, valued a diverse range of socio-economic benefits. Informal conservation areas formed integral parts of the conservation-orientated landscape, rating benefits equally to more secure mechanisms. Private land must be incorporated into conservation through diverse mechanisms to meet the range of mutually exclusive conservation objectives of the 21st century