Barotropic f-plane dipolar vortices were generated in a rotating fluid and a comparison was made with the so-called supersmooth f-plane solution which-in contrast to the classical Lamb-Chaplygin solution-is marked by an elliptical separatrix and a doubly continuously differentiable vorticity field. Dye-visualization and high-resolution particle-tracking techniques revealed that the observed dipole characteristics (separatrix aspect ratio, cross-sectional vorticity distribution and vorticity versus streamfunction relationship) are in close agreement with those of the supersmooth f-plane solution for the entire lifespan of the dipolar vortex. © 2009 The Author(s)