Daily, Immediate Conflicts: an Analysis of Villagers Arguments about a Multinational Nickel Mining Project in New Caledonia

Local communities are not the homogenous entities, unanimously opposed to industrial development, that academic and popular literature often portray them to be. In this paper, I discuss my research in New Caledonian villages near a potential mining project. I analyse the diversity of individuals' responses to industrial activities, the intra-community conflicts that this development triggered or exacerbated, and the discourses that people implemented to support their positions. Specifically, people's statements - and, presumably, beliefs - about dangers from ecological damage and ancestral anger reflected their expectations of the project's consequences for their sub-group's social status. I argue that, through their interactions with the mining company, what many if not most of these villagers primarily sought was respect of their social positions and control of their own destinies. They especially aspired to determine what happened to their land, the source of their identity and dignity