Learning is Change in Knowledge: Knowledge-based Security for Dynamic Policies

In systems that handle confidential information, the security policy to enforce on information frequently changes: new users join the system, old users leave, and sensitivity of data changes over time. It is challenging, yet important, to specify what it means for such systems to be secure, and to gain assurance that a system is secure. We present a language-based model for specifying, reasoning about, and enforcing information security in systems that dynamically change the security policy. We specify security for such systems as a simple and intuitive extensional knowledge-based semantic condition: an attacker can only learn information in accordance with the current security policy. Importantly, the semantic condition is parameterized by the ability of the attacker. Learning is about change in knowledge, and an observation that allows one attacker to learn confidential information may provide a different attacker with no new information. A program that is secure against an attacker with perfect recall may not be secure against a more realistic, weaker, attacker. We introduce a compositional model of attackers that simplifies enforcement of security, and demonstrate that standard information-flow control mechanisms, such as security-type systems and information-flow monitors, can be easily adapted to enforce security for a broad and useful class of attackers.Engineering and Applied Science