A comparison of lipoprotein measurements from the Dallas Heart Study

Conventional cholesterol markers in clinical practice today may systematically underestimate the true atherosclerotic risk of populations with high prevalence of metabolic perturbations. It has been suggested that atherogenic risk indexes that measure the concentration of atherogenic particle concentration rather then cholesterol may improve the recognition of atherogenic risk in a clinical setting. Particle concentration is strongly correlated with cholesterol markers, but only a fair concordance with cholesterol has been seen in male populations with low prevalence of metabolic perturbations. Little is known about the concordance of particle concentration and cholesterol markers in multiethnic populations with high prevalence of metabolic perturbations including both men and women. Furthermore, no study has looked at atherosclerosis while exploring the concordance of particle concentration and cholesterol. NMR total atherogenic particle concentration (LipoScience, Inc.), Non-HDL-C, and coronary CT were performed on 3054 subjects ages 30-65 from the Dallas Heart Study, a multi-ethnic probability-based population study. Patients were stratified into four groups: subjects with a low Non-HDL-C and low particle concentration (n = 929), subjects with high Non-HDL-C and low particle concentration (n = 88), subjects with low Non-HDL-C and high particle concentration, and subjects with high Non-HDL-C and high particle concentration (n = 950). When discordance was defined as two quintiles or more of disagreement, discordant groups were relatively small (n= 389, 12.6% of population). There was no statistically significant difference in prevalence of coronary calcification for the group with high Non-HDL-C and low particle concentration compared to the group with low Non-HDL-C and low particle concentration. The discordant group with low Non-HDL-C and low particle concentration, which included 88 subjects, had the highest prevalence of coronary calcification out of the four groups. Out of the 3054 subjects tested in this study, 88 subjects were considered to be part of the discordant group with low Non-HDL-C and a high particle concentration. Although this group is relatively small and comprise approximately 3% of the total population, they did have the highest prevalence of coronary calcification.