Pathways Across the Valley of Death: Novel Intellectual Property Strategies for Accelerated Drug Discovery

Most therapeutic interventions produced by pharmaceutical firms take the form of small molecule drugs, which are mass produced at low marginal cost and ingested orally. Drug therapies typically work by affecting the activity of human proteins, known in the industry as targets, that have been implicated in disease pathways. Thus far, medical science has identified safe and effective therapies for only a few hundred of the estimated 3000 protein targets in the human genome that are potentially susceptible to a drug. Moreover, pharmaceutical firms have encountered major obstacles in producing fundamentally new small molecule drugs, especially those that work against new targets. According to one report, an average of only three drugs that act on novel targets have reached the market annually in recent years. This highly visible problem has attracted commentary in scholarly articles, government white papers, and the popular press. Government agencies, such as the National Institutes of Health, and industry insiders, have also recognized that one of the most serious pitfalls involves the difficulty of moving across the so-called valley of death that separates upstream research on promising genes, proteins, and biological pathways from downstream drug candidates. For example, an upstream finding that a given protein is differentially expressed in individuals with a particular disease may suggest that the protein merits further investigation. However, much more work (especially medicinal chemistry) is necessary to determine how good a target the protein really is and whether a marketable drug candidate that affects the activity of the protein is likely to be developed