Co-operatives and the Equity-Liabilities Puzzle: Concerns for Accounting Standards Setters

The IASB/FASB joint project on Financial Instruments with Characteristics of Equity (formerly Liabilities and Equity) has highlighted the complexity and the associated difficulty of drawing the line between liabilities and equity. While classification difficulties have been identified for investor-owned businesses (IOB), the inconsistency of the different approaches being considered is clearer when applied to classification of the financial instruments of co-operatives whose ownership characteristics differ from the IOB model. In co-operatives the existence of an upper limit on members¿ claims on the net assets while the co-operative is a going concern is a key ownership characteristic. We have examined the characteristics of co-operative member shares in six European countries as well as in the U.S. and in Canada, in order to analyze the application of the various classification approaches under discussion by the IASB and FASB. The results of this analysis indicate that classification criteria based on ownership must take account of the fact that ownership is multidimensional and contingent on the type of firm.López-Espinosa, G.; Maddocks, J.; Polo Garrido, F. (2012). Co-operatives and the Equity-Liabilities Puzzle: Concerns for Accounting Standards Setters. Accounting Horizons. 26(4):767-787. doi:10.2308/acch-50208S767787264Arruñada, B. 1998. Teoría contractual de la empresa. Editorial Marcial Pons. Available at:http://arrunada.org/Files/T/uom/Programa%20OEM%20esp.pdfBirchall, J. 2011. A “member-owned business” approach to the classification of co-operatives and mutuals. Journal of Co-operative Studies 44 (2): 4–15.Botosan, C. A., Koonce, L., Ryan, S. G., Stone, M. S., & Wahlen, J. M. (2005). Accounting for Liabilities: Conceptual Issues, Standard Setting, and Evidence from Academic Research. Accounting Horizons, 19(3), 159-186. doi:10.2308/acch.2005.19.3.159Canadian Institute of Chartered Accountants (CICA). 1996a. EIC-72 Presentation of Members' Shares in a Co-operative Organization as Liabilities or Equity. Available at:http://www.cica.ca/publications/list-of-publications/manual/item33729.pdfChaddad, F. R., & Cook, M. L. (2004). Understanding New Cooperative Models: An Ownership-Control Rights Typology. Review of Agricultural Economics, 26(3), 348-360. doi:10.1111/j.1467-9353.2004.00184.xClark, M. 1993. Entity theory, modern capital structure theory, and the distinction between debt and equity. Accounting Horizons 7 (1): 135–156.European Association of Co-operative Banks (EACB). 2007. Survey on Co-operative Shares and Other Equity Instruments Issued By Co-operatives. Brussels, Belgium: EACB.Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB). 2006. Summary of Principles of Ownership Approach. Available at: http://www.fasb.orgFinancial Accounting Standards Board (FASB). 2007. Preliminary Views, Financial Instruments with Characteristics of Equity. Available at:http://www.fasb.orgHopkins, P. E. (1996). The Effect of Financial Statement Classification of Hybrid Financial Instruments on Financial Analysts’ Stock Price Judgments. Journal of Accounting Research, 34, 33. doi:10.2307/2491424(2009). Response to the FASB’s Preliminary Views on Financial Instruments with the Characteristics of Equity. Accounting Horizons, 23(1), 85-100. doi:10.2308/acch.2009.23.1.85International Accounting Standards Board (IASB). 2002. Exposure Draft of Proposed Amendments to IAS 32 Financial Instruments: Disclosure, andFinancial Instruments:Recognition and Measurement. Presentation 3. Available at:http://www.iasb.orgInternational Accounting Standards Board (IASB). 2004. IFRIC Interpretation 2 Members' Shares in Co-operative Entities and Similar Instruments. Available at:http://www.iasb.orgInternational Accounting Standards Board (IASB). 2006. Exposure Draft of Proposed Amendments to IAS 32 Financial Instruments, and IAS 1 Presentation of Financial Statements, Financial Instruments Puttable At Fair Value, and Obligations Arising on Liquidation. Available at:http://www.iasb.orgInternational Co-operative Alliance (ICA) 1995. Statement on the Co-operative Identity. Available at:http://www.coop.org/coop/principles.htmlInternational Co-operative Alliance (ICA). 2008. Global 300 List 2008: The World's Major Co-operatives and Mutual Businesses. Available at:http://www.global300.coop/sites/global300.dev.xeriom.net/files/launchlist.pdfKimmel, P. and T. D. Warfield. 1995. The usefulness of hybrid security classifications: evidence from redeemable preferred stock. The Accounting Review 70 (1): 151–167.Kirschenheiter, M., Mathur, R., & Thomas, J. K. (2004). Accounting for Employee Stock Options. Accounting Horizons, 18(2), 135-156. doi:10.2308/acch.2004.18.2.135Lewellyn, D. T. 2004. Issues in the Governance of Mutuals in the Finance Sector. Available at:http://62.164.176.164/d/myners_llewellyn.pdfMyners, P. 2004. Myners Review of the Governance of Life Mutuals: Final Report. Available at:http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20080107205614/hm-treasury.gov.uk/independent_reviews/myners_review/review_myners_index.cfmNational Cooperative Business Association (NCBA). 2008. Letter of Comment No. 31 to Preliminary Views, Financial Instruments with Characteristics of Equity of FASB. Available at:http://www.fasb.org/cs/BlobServer?blobkey=id&blobwhere=1175818444151&blobheader=application%2Fpdf&blobcol=urldata&blobtable=MungoBlobsNational Society of Accountants for Co-operartives (NSAC). 2008. Letter of Comment No. 30 to Preliminary Views, Financial Instruments with Characteristics of Equity of FASB. Available at:http://www.fasb.org/cs/BlobServer?blobkey=id&blobwhere=1175818443966&blobheader=application%2Fpdf&blobcol=urldata&blobtable=MungoBlobsSingleton-Green, B. and R. Hodgkinson. 2010. Business Models in Accounting: The Theory of the Firm and Financial Reporting. Available at:http://www.icaew.com/~/media/Files/Technical/Financial-reporting/Information%20for%20better%20markets/BMIA%20published%20report.pd