Models for value-added modeling of teacher effects

The use of complex value-added models that attempt to isolate the contributions of teachers or schools to student development is increasing. Several variations on these models are being applied in the research literature, and policy makers have expressed interest in using these models for evaluating teachers and schools. In this article, we present a general multivariate, longitudinal mixed-model that incorporates the complex grouping structures inherent to longitudinal student data linked to teachers. We summarize the principal existing modeling approaches, show how these approaches are special cases of the proposed model, and discuss possible extensions to model more complex data structures. We present simula-tion and analytical results that clarify the interplay between estimated teacher effects and repeated outcomes on students over time. We also explore the poten-tial impact of model misspecifications, including missing student covariates and assumptions about the accumulation of teacher effects over time, on key infer-ences made from the models. We conclude that mixed models that account for stu-dent correlation over time are reasonably robust to such misspecifications when all the schools in the sample serve similar student populations. However, student characteristics are likely to confound estimated teacher effects when schools serve distinctly different populations