Growing Two-sided Networks by Advertising the User Base: A Field Experiment

Two-sided exchange networks (such as eBay) often advertise their number of users, pre-sumably to encourage further participation. However, these networks differ markedly on how they advertise their user base. Some highlight the number of sellers, some empha-size the number of buyers, and others disclose both. We use field experiment data from a business-to-business web site to examine the efficacy of these different display formats. Before each potential seller posted a listing, the web site randomized whether to display the number of buyers and/or sellers, and if so how many buyers and/or sellers to claim. We find that when information about both buyers and sellers is displayed, a large number of sellers deters further seller listings. However, this deterrence effect disappears when only the number of sellers is presented. Similarly, a large number of buyers is more likely to attract new listings when it is displayed together with the number of sellers. These results suggest the presence of indirect network externalities, whereby a seller prefers markets with many other sellers because they help attract more buyers