Strategies for dissenting scientists Those who challenge conventional views or vested interests in science are likely to encounter difficulties. A scientific dissenter should first of all realize that science is a system of power as well as knowledge, in which interest groups play a key role and insiders have an extra advantage. Dissenters are likely to be ignored or dismissed. If they gain some recognition or outside support, they may be attacked. In the face of such obstacles, there are several strategies, including mimicking science, aiming at lower status outlets, enlisting patrons, seeking a different audience, exposing suppression of dissent, and building a social movement
In a recent article in this journal—“Who’s Afraid of Dissent?”—Immaculada de Melo-Martín and Kristen...
William Lynch’s Minority Report is the most comprehensive and fair-minded attempt to give epistemic ...
Science is under attack and scientists are becoming more involved in efforts to defend it. The rise ...
Dissent is questioning or challenging an established idea, practice, or policy. It occurs in all sor...
Includes bibliographical references and index.Dissent and its discontents -- The important roles of ...
A scientist publishes a research paper questioning the dominant view on global warming. A minister g...
and consequences of scientific controversy, no coherent theory of scientific dissent has emerged. Th...
When the work and reputation of scientists suffer ritual degradation, a range of tactics can be depl...
Critics of powerful individuals or systems are sometimes suppressed: they are attacked using various...
Recent philosophical literature has highlighted the complexities of handling dissent in science. On ...
We are thinking beings. Given the faculty of free will and the innumerable circumstances that we fin...
Several prominent voices have called for a democratization of science through deliberative processes...
The analysis of dissent, or the mobilization of scientific claims to challenge existing political ar...
Supporters of dominant scientific theories sometimes attack competing, less favoured theories in way...
Scientists whose work and reputation come under fire may adopt strategic practices to protect and re...
In a recent article in this journal—“Who’s Afraid of Dissent?”—Immaculada de Melo-Martín and Kristen...
William Lynch’s Minority Report is the most comprehensive and fair-minded attempt to give epistemic ...
Science is under attack and scientists are becoming more involved in efforts to defend it. The rise ...
Dissent is questioning or challenging an established idea, practice, or policy. It occurs in all sor...
Includes bibliographical references and index.Dissent and its discontents -- The important roles of ...
A scientist publishes a research paper questioning the dominant view on global warming. A minister g...
and consequences of scientific controversy, no coherent theory of scientific dissent has emerged. Th...
When the work and reputation of scientists suffer ritual degradation, a range of tactics can be depl...
Critics of powerful individuals or systems are sometimes suppressed: they are attacked using various...
Recent philosophical literature has highlighted the complexities of handling dissent in science. On ...
We are thinking beings. Given the faculty of free will and the innumerable circumstances that we fin...
Several prominent voices have called for a democratization of science through deliberative processes...
The analysis of dissent, or the mobilization of scientific claims to challenge existing political ar...
Supporters of dominant scientific theories sometimes attack competing, less favoured theories in way...
Scientists whose work and reputation come under fire may adopt strategic practices to protect and re...
In a recent article in this journal—“Who’s Afraid of Dissent?”—Immaculada de Melo-Martín and Kristen...
William Lynch’s Minority Report is the most comprehensive and fair-minded attempt to give epistemic ...
Science is under attack and scientists are becoming more involved in efforts to defend it. The rise ...