Sums of possibly associated bernoulli variables: The conwaymaxwell-binomial distribution. arXiv preprint arXiv:1404.1856

Abstract. The study of sums of possibly associated Bernoulli random variables has been hampered by an asymmetry between positive correlation and negative correlation. The Conway-Maxwell Binomial (COMB) distribution and its multivariate extension, the Conway-Maxwell Multinomial (COMM) distribution, gracefully model both positive and negative association. Sufficient statistics and a family of proper conjugate distributions are found. The relationship of this distribution to the exchangeable special case is ex-plored, and two applications are discussed. 1. Sums of Possibly Associated Bernoulli Variables There often are reasons to suggest that Bernoulli random variables, while identically dis-tributed, may not be independent. For example, suppose pots are planted with six seeds each, where each pot has seeds from a unique plant, but different pot’s seeds came from different plants. Suppose that success of a seedling is well-defined. If genetic similarity is the dominant source of non-independence, it is reasonable to suppose positive association. However, if competition for nutrients and sunlight predominates, association could be neg-ative. Hence, it makes sense to find a functional form that gracefully allows for either positive or negative association. “Association ” here means something more general than correlation. Correlation is a particular measure of association, familiar because of its connection with the normal dis-tribution, and its simple relationship to certain expectations. However, there is no partic-ular reason why correlation should be used in non-normal situations if it has undesirable properties. The desire for a functional form that allows for both positive and negative association runs into the following familiar fact, which is well-known, but for completeness is proved in Appendix A: Proposition 1. Suppose X1,..., Xm have (possibly different) means and variances and common pairwise correlations ρ. Then ρ ≥ −1/(m − 1). There are (at least) three different possible strategies for dealing with the asymmetry between positive and negative correlation revealed by the proposition: a) abandon correlation as a measure of association b) abandon exchangeability of the Bernoulli random variables 1 a