The dilemma of free will is that if actions are caused deter-ministically, then they are not free, and if they are not caused deterministically then they are not free either because then they happen by chance and are not up to the agent. I shall propose a conception of free will that solves this dilemma. It may seem to many metaphysically more extravagant than other conceptions but I shall suggest that this should not deter us. However, I shall not undertake here to argue that there really are beings with free will; this would be a different project. Here I shall only discuss what free actions would be like. Imagine a tidal wave at time t2 that was caused by an earth-quake in the sea at time t1. There was a causal process, de-scribed by law...