T.: Lost in abstraction: Monotonicity in multi-threaded programs (extended technical report

Abstract. Monotonicity in concurrent systems stipulates that, in any global state, extant system actions remain executable when new processes are added to the state. This concept is not only natural and common in multi-threaded software, but also useful: if every thread’s memory is finite, monotonicity often guaran-tees the decidability of safety property verification even when the number of running threads is unknown. In this paper, we show that the act of obtaining finite-data thread abstractions for model checking can be at odds with mono-tonicity: Predicate-abstracting certain widely used monotone software results in non-monotone multi-threaded Boolean programs — the monotonicity is lost in the abstraction. As a result, well-established sound and complete safety checking algorithms become inapplicable; in fact, safety checking turns out to be undecid-able for the obtained class of unbounded-thread Boolean programs. We demon-strate how the abstract programs can be modified into monotone ones, without affecting safety properties of the non-monotone abstraction. This significantly improves earlier approaches of enforcing monotonicity via overapproximations.