1 ECO-PREMIUM OR ECO-PENALTY? ECO-LABELS AND QUALITY IN THE ORGANIC WINE MARKET

Eco-labels emphasize information disclosure as a tool to induce environmentally friendly behaviors by both firms and consumers. The goal of eco-labels is to reduce information asymmetry between producers and consumers over the environmental attributes of a product or service. However, by focusing on this information asymmetry, rather than how the label meets consumer needs, eco-labels may send irrelevant, confusing or even detrimental messages to consumers. In this paper, we investigate how the environmental signal of eco-labels interacts with product characteristics such as brand, quality and price. In a discrete choice experiment the authors examine consumer response to two similar eco-labels for wine, one associated with a quality reduction and the other not. Our results show that respondents preferred both eco-labeled wines over otherwise identical conventional counterparts, when the price was lower and the wine was from a lower quality region. However they preferred conventional more expensive wine from a high quality region. This indicates that respondents obtain some warm glow value from eco-labeled wine, but also possibly interpret it as a signal of lower quality. This relationship held across both types of eco-labels, meaning that consumers did not understand the difference between them. Our research contribute