Failure to migrate: lack of tree range expansion in response to climate change. Global Change Biology

Tree species are expected to track warming climate by shifting their ranges to higher latitudes or elevations, but cur-rent evidence of latitudinal range shifts for suites of species is largely indirect. In response to global warming, off-spring of trees are predicted to have ranges extend beyond adults at leading edges and the opposite relationship at trailing edges. Large-scale forest inventory data provide an opportunity to compare present latitudes of seedlings and adult trees at their range limits. Using the USDA Forest Service’s Forest Inventory and Analysis data, we directly compared seedling and tree 5th and 95th percentile latitudes for 92 species in 30 longitudinal bands for 43 334 plots across the eastern United States. We further compared these latitudes with 20th century temperature and precipita-tion change and functional traits, including seed size and seed spread rate. Results suggest that 58.7 % of the tree spe-cies examined show the pattern expected for a population undergoing range contraction, rather than expansion, at both northern and southern boundaries. Fewer species show a pattern consistent with a northward shift (20.7%) and fewer still with a southward shift (16.3%). Only 4.3 % are consistent with expansion at both range limits. When com-pared with the 20th century climate changes that have occurred at the range boundaries themselves, there is no con-sistent evidence that population spread is greatest in areas where climate has changed most; nor are patterns related to seed size or dispersal characteristics. The fact that the majority of seedling extreme latitudes are less than those for adult trees may emphasize the lack of evidence for climate-mediated migration, and should increase concerns for the risks posed by climate change