Getting Unstuck: Interdisciplinarity as a New Discipline

Abstract: Most disciplines and sub-disciplines consider their particular specialization to be valuable in itself and superior to other disciplines. But compared with the huge leaps in the physical sciences, the social/behavioral sciences and humanities have made little progress. Since many of the physical science advances were the result of the merging of disciplines, perhaps interdisciplinarity should be tried. One path to connecting disciplines, sub-disciplines, and micro-macro levels is suggested by Spinoza’s idea of part/whole methodology, exactly balancing concrete instances with abstract theses. Ideas by Pascal, A. Koestler, A. N. Whitehead, and E. O. Wilson may also be helpful. Any discipline, sub-discipline or level can serve as a valuable stepping-off place, but to advance further, integration with at least one other viewpoint may be necessary. Two brilliant examples are The Civilizing Process, by the sociologist Norbert Elias, and Freudian Repression, by the psychologist Michael Billig. Koestler’s idea of “bi-sociation ” may prove to be particularly rewarding. The way that Virginia Woolf’s depiction of role-taking in interior monologue preceded the idea in social science is an extraordinary example. The need for integration may be the single most important issu