Teaching Motion Gestures via Recognizer Feedback

When using motion gestures, 3D movements of a mobile phone, as an input modality, one significant challenge is how to teach end users the movement parameters necessary to successfully issue a command. Is a simple video or image depicting movement of a smartphone sufficient? Or do we need three-dimensional depictions of movement on external screens to train users? In this paper, we explore mechanisms to teach end users motion gestures, examining two factors. The first factor is how to represent motion gestures: as icons that describe movement, video that depicts movement using the smartphone screen, or a Kinect-based teaching mechanism that captures and depicts the gesture on an external display in three-dimensional space. The second factor we explore is recognizer feedback, i.e. a simple representation of the proximity of a motion gesture to the desired motion gesture based on a distance metric extracted from the recognizer. We show that, by combining video with recognizer feedback, participants master motion gestures equally quickly as end users that learn using a Kinect. These results demonstrate the viability of training end users to perform motion gestures using only the smartphone display