A Systematic Analysis of Errors in the Simplification of a Rational Expression

Exploring the errors that mathematics students frequently make is a means by which teachers can gain a better understanding of students ’ difficulties. Reported here are the process by which the algebraic working of 95 undergraduate students who incorrectly simplified a rational expression was analysed and the results of the analysis. Initially, a deductive approach to analysing the errors was planned, categorising students ’ mistakes using the error types identified, named and described in the literature. In reviewing the literature, however, it became clear that this would be no simple task. The large body of literature, while rich in examples of “typical errors ” that could be expected in students ’ working, had two limitations. Firstly, the error types lacked precise descriptions and were mainly described by example only. Secondly, insufficient details of the procedures used to categorise the errors prevented replication of the categorising process. Consequently, a mainly inductive approach, that categorised the errors by their location and inferred student operation was devised. This systematic approach resulted in generating descriptions of three error categories