An Update on the Comparisons of Mortality Outcomes of Hemodialysis and Peritoneal Dialysis Patients

The number of dialysis patients continues to grow. In many parts of the world, peritoneal dialysis (PD) is a less expensive form of treatment. However, it has been questioned whether patients treated with PD can have as good a long-term outcome as that achieved with hemodialysis (HD). This skepticism has fueled ongoing comparisons of outcomes of patients treated with in-center HD and PD using data from national registries, or prospective cohort studies. There are major challenges in comparing outcomes with two therapies when the treatment assignment is non-random. Furthermore, many of the inter-modality comparisons include patients who started dialysis therapy in the 1990s. In many parts of the world, improvements in PD outcome have outpaced those seen with in-center HD. It is not surprising, then, that virtually all the recent observational studies from different parts of the world consistently show that long-term survival of HD and PD patients is remarkably similar. These studies support the case for a greater use of PD for the treatment of end-stage renal disease – this, in turn, could allow more patients to be treated for any given budgetary allocation to long-term dialysis. Ever since the initial successful experience with continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysi