South African Manufacturing Industry Structure and its Implications for Competition Policy

This paper surveys the literature on the manufacturing sector in South Africa, focusing on concentration and markup levels, with a view to inform policy. The literature has employed a number of di¤erent measures of industrial concentration, namely, the Gini and Rosenbluth indices, the Occupancy Count, the C5 % index and, to a lesser extent, Concentration Ratios and the Her\u85ndahl-Hirschman index. Generally, manufacturing industry concentration is found to be high and increasing up to 1996. However, all the measures show decreasing concentration post 1996. In respect of markups, the evidence suggests that markups in South Africa are signi\u85cantly higher than they are in comparable industries world-wide and they appear to be non-declining. However, there are dissenting voices on this point. We then juxtapose the concentration and price-cost margins \u85ndings to industry performance (at the macro level). In particular, we review the literature that examines the relations between concentration and price-cost margins on the one hand and output growth, productivity growth, employment, employment growth, investment and export and import competitiveness on the other. We then draw implications for competition policy in South Africa, pointing out areas that need further research as well as international best practices